Guides
UK construction

Why Subcontractor Payments in UK Construction Are Broken, and How to Fix the Back Office

Seven reasons paying subbies is still so manual in UK construction, why the compliance risk now sits with the contractor, and what an automated back office changes.

Petl Pay team
March 20, 2026
November 11, 2026
3
Why Subcontractor Payments in UK Construction Are Broken, and How to Fix the Back Office

Quick answer

Subbie payments break because the information you need to pay someone correctly lives in too many places: WhatsApp, email, paper timesheets, spreadsheets and the bank. Fixing it means one record per subbie and per job, CIS worked out on every payment, and a pay run that takes minutes to approve rather than a day to rebuild.

The job's moved on. The back office hasn't.

UK construction runs on subbies: builders, electricians, groundworkers, plasterers, bricklayers and fit-out firms, paid weekly by the contractors who bring them onto jobs. The site side has changed a lot. The back office behind it mostly hasn't. Paying subbies is still a weekly patchwork of WhatsApp, email, invoices, paper and spreadsheets, with no single place that holds the whole picture.

Seven reasons it breaks

1. Tax worked out by hand on every payment

Every subbie has a CIS rate of 0%, 20% or 30%, and it only applies to labour, not materials. Get it wrong and the contractor owes HMRC the difference. Doing that by hand across dozens of subbies every week is where mistakes creep in.

2. Pay runs rebuilt from scratch every week

Claims arrive in different formats from different people. Someone has to pull them together, check them, work out deductions, key in payments and update the books. Next week, they do it all again.

3. Compliance risk now sits with the contractor

From 6 April 2026, nil CIS returns came back and HMRC got tougher powers over gross payment status. From 1 October 2026, right to work checks extended to individual subcontractors. And Making Tax Digital for Income Tax is rolling out to sole traders from April 2026. Each change adds checks the contractor needs to be able to prove.

4. No system of record

The data you need is scattered across point solutions and paper. When HMRC or a client asks a question, the answer has to be rebuilt by hand.

5. Bureaus that still leave the work with you

Payroll bureaus take the processing off your hands, but you're usually still collecting timesheets, chasing subbies and handling disputes, and the records often sit in their system rather than yours.

6. Paying a chain, not a payroll

Money moves from client to contractor to subcontracting firm to individual subbie, often before the client has paid. Tools built for one employer and its employees don't fit that shape.

7. A workforce that runs on phones

Most subbies work from a phone, not a laptop. Clock-in apps and desktop accounting software get ignored, so the information never makes it into the system in the first place.

What a fixed back office looks like

  • Onboarding once. Subbies add their own UTR and bank details through a link. Their CIS rate is set once.
  • Work logged where it happens. On a phone, in apps they already use, against the right job.
  • CIS on every payment. Calculated automatically on labour only, with materials kept separate.
  • You approve, then pay. Nothing goes out without sign-off, and every payment is kept on record.
  • Books that update themselves. Payments and deductions pushed to Xero on the right lines.
  • Your choice of who does the admin. Run it yourself, or have it done for you with an accountant.

The goal is simple: you build, and the back office stops eating your Thursdays.

How Petl Pay helps

Petl Pay is the automated back office for UK contractors and their subbies. Subbies add their own UTR and bank details through one link, work gets logged on WhatsApp, the Petl Pay app, ChatGPT or Claude (or by a project manager on their behalf), and each subbie's CIS rate is set once and applied to every payment, on labour only.

You approve every payment, pay by bank or download a BACS file, and push payments and CIS deductions to Xero. Petl Pay calculates and tracks CIS and produces your monthly return data. It doesn't file with HMRC: send the return to your accountant, or have our accountant partner file it for you. Petl Pay never holds your funds.

See how it works for construction, take the 2-minute Back Office Check, or book a call.

Check before you act. Petl Pay calculates and tracks CIS. It doesn't file returns for you. Rules change, so check the latest guidance at hmrc.gov.uk or have it done with an accountant.

FAQs

Is a payroll bureau the same as subcontractor payment software?

No. A bureau runs the process for you, usually charging per worker, while you still collect timesheets and handle disputes. Software gives you the record and the automation so you can run it yourself, or have it run for you with an accountant.

Why is the contractor responsible for CIS mistakes?

Because CIS makes the paying contractor responsible for verifying subcontractors, deducting the right amount and filing the monthly return. If you under-deduct or file late, the penalties and the tax shortfall come to you.

Do subbies need to download an app?

Not with Petl Pay. Subbies can log work on WhatsApp, ChatGPT or Claude, or a project manager can log it for them. The Petl Pay app is there for those who want it.

Can my existing accountant work with Petl Pay?

Yes. Petl Pay produces the payments, CIS deductions and monthly return data, and pushes them to Xero. Your accountant can file from that, or our accountant partner can do it for you.

Petl Pay team
Payments, CIS and compliance for UK construction

Petl Pay is the automated back office for UK contractors and their subbies, covering payments, compliance and tax in one place.

Petl Pay on LinkedIn

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules change, so check gov.uk or speak to a qualified adviser before you act on it.

Share this post

Spend less time and money on back-office admin

Help with payments, compliance and tax for contractors and the teams they pay, in one place.

Petl Pay never holds your funds.

By clicking “Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.